---------------------------------------
Hi all,
Thank you all for your contribution to the
meeting last Tuesday. I think it was very useful, and I got the idea
that this feeling was mutual.
Here is the report Maarten van Someren and me made.
With kind regards,
Maarten
-------------------------------------
Report Meeting Master AI (19 June 2012)
Present: Maarten van Someren (OC, chair and minutes), Maarten van der Velden (OC), Frank Aldershof, Christof Monz, Gwenn Englebienne, Shimon Whiteson and about 15 students (a mix of first and second year masters, and of UvA and external bachelors)
Entry requirements / prior knowledge:
• Important things are: MATLAB, linear algebra, calculus, statistics
• The schedule leaves little time to catch up with this on the side
• Maybe it is better to start with the maths and then go to the (ML) algorithms, to make sure that students understand this
• Is it possible to have an optional refreshment course?
• Maybe make a little test on the 4 topics, or point to a book / video / exercises so that students can test their level and maybe study a bit before the master starts
• Set up a little test on basics in the first week and offer help to those with problems?
First semester:
• NLP course duplicates Bachelor; this is almost impossible to avoid; maybe accept duplication and waive this for students who can prove that they know the material. Especially in a 3 EC course one cannot repeat and add new material.
• Idea of common / overview is OK
• Level of course in general OK
• Better to set Computer Vision before Int. Multimedia Systems; Int. Multimedia should then be more structured, have more content and depth
• Information Retrieval could be more difficult
• Courses in second semester / track hardly build on first semester
Rest of programme:
• Students would like to have more choice in courses, especially in the second semester; this makes it possible to reach more depth in a topic; these courses can also be elsewhere in UvA, VU or other
• Structure of programme in tracks may not be necessary, perhaps only to explain the main topics in the programme
• Announce that it is possible to do a project in Free Choice credits; is it possible to do a project as track/AI course?
• 8-‐8-‐4 schedule: mostly positive; courses need to be adapted; little room to catch up
• The topics for profile projects should be announced a week before the project starts so that students can choose
Support:
• It would be good if teachers/assistants have a fixed time where students can ask questions (i.e. schedule an office hour a week during the course)
General:
• Some courses provide no feedback on projects/practical work; this type of feedback would be very instructive and useful
• Some exam questions are repeated; this should not happen
• Deadlines for grading are not met
• OC AI should communicate more with students, e.g. by maintaining a webpage on Blackboard with minutes on meetings, room for discussion, etc.
• A meeting like this is quite useful; should be organized on a regular basis
