Thursday, June 21, 2012

Not everyone received Maarten's email today, so I'll post it here:

---------------------------------------

Hi all,

Thank you all for your contribution to the meeting last Tuesday. I think it was very useful, and I got the idea that this feeling was mutual.

Here is the report Maarten van Someren and me made.

With kind regards,

Maarten
 

 -------------------------------------


Report  Meeting  Master  AI  (19  June  2012) 

Present:  Maarten  van  Someren  (OC,  chair  and  minutes),  Maarten  van  der  Velden  (OC),  Frank   Aldershof,  Christof  Monz,  Gwenn  Englebienne,  Shimon  Whiteson  and  about  15  students  (a  mix  of   first  and  second  year  masters,  and  of  UvA  and  external  bachelors)  
 

Entry  requirements  /  prior  knowledge: 

• Important  things  are:  MATLAB,  linear  algebra,  calculus,  statistics  
• The  schedule  leaves  little  time  to  catch  up  with  this  on  the  side  
• Maybe  it  is  better  to  start  with  the  maths  and  then  go  to  the  (ML)  algorithms,  to  make  sure   that  students  understand  this  
• Is  it  possible  to  have  an  optional  refreshment  course?    
• Maybe  make  a  little  test  on  the  4  topics,  or  point  to  a  book  /  video  /  exercises  so  that   students  can  test  their  level  and  maybe  study  a  bit  before  the  master  starts  
• Set  up  a  little  test  on  basics  in  the  first  week  and  offer  help  to  those  with  problems?  
 

First  semester: 

• NLP  course  duplicates  Bachelor;  this  is  almost  impossible  to  avoid;  maybe  accept  duplication   and  waive  this  for  students  who  can  prove  that  they  know  the  material.  Especially  in  a  3  EC   course  one  cannot  repeat  and  add  new  material.  
• Idea  of  common  /  overview  is  OK  
• Level  of  course  in  general  OK  
• Better  to  set  Computer  Vision  before  Int.  Multimedia  Systems;    Int.    Multimedia  should  then   be  more  structured,  have  more  content  and  depth  
• Information  Retrieval  could  be  more  difficult  
• Courses  in  second  semester  /  track  hardly  build  on  first  semester  
 

Rest  of  programme: 

• Students  would  like  to  have  more  choice  in  courses,  especially  in  the  second  semester;  this   makes  it  possible  to  reach  more  depth  in  a  topic;  these  courses  can  also  be  elsewhere  in  UvA,   VU  or  other  
• Structure  of  programme  in  tracks  may  not  be  necessary,  perhaps  only  to  explain  the  main   topics  in  the  programme  
• Announce  that  it  is  possible  to  do  a  project  in  Free  Choice  credits;  is  it  possible  to  do  a   project  as  track/AI  course?  
• 8-­‐8-­‐4  schedule:  mostly  positive;  courses  need  to  be  adapted;  little  room  to  catch  up  
• The  topics  for  profile  projects  should  be  announced  a  week  before  the  project  starts  so  that   students  can  choose


Support: 

• It  would  be  good  if  teachers/assistants  have  a  fixed  time  where  students  can  ask  questions   (i.e.  schedule  an  office  hour  a  week  during  the  course)  
 

General: 

• Some  courses  provide  no  feedback  on  projects/practical  work;  this  type  of  feedback  would   be  very  instructive  and  useful  
• Some  exam  questions  are  repeated;  this  should  not  happen  
• Deadlines  for  grading  are  not  met  
• OC  AI  should  communicate  more  with  students,  e.g.  by  maintaining  a  webpage  on   Blackboard  with  minutes  on  meetings,  room  for  discussion,  etc.  
• A  meeting  like  this  is  quite  useful;  should  be  organized  on  a  regular  basis  

No comments:

Post a Comment